Simple answer - every single student needs care.
Complex answer - different students need different levels of care from just needing to know that they are not invisible or that what they do does not go unnoticed, to unpacking the emotional trauma of previous and current experiences.
Here is a key to working out who needs your care - ask yourself...
"Is this kid okay? Are they coping? Do they need reassurance or something more?"
You need to work out how you are going to identify the students that you want to care for. I spend a lot of time and effort making sure my kids line up properly and walk through the door properly. As they walk in I look at most of their faces to see if there are any changes or if someone is generally looking unhappy. It's not an exact science and I check my gut feeling by watching any students who look particularly down by watching them during the lesson. In actual fact, it's not the students who look sad or tired you should be worried about, but the ones who have anger as the dominant expression - eyebrows drawn together, flexing jaw muscle, deadpan eyes. These are the students who are probably dealing with the worst (either self inflicted or not) and are most likely to actually respond - sometimes violently. I have inserted a picture of 6 facial expressions for you to look at and think about in terms of your students - who in your classes wears these expressions normally?
There are of course other ways. You can get a referal - a teacher coming up to you and saying "are you [name]'s form teacher? I'm just a bit worried about them." Maybe it's just that you notice a student sitting by themselves at lunch. Sometimes a student will say something in class which is a bit off, or a bit unusual that might just make you think "Is this kid okay? Are they coping? Do they need reassurance or something more?"
I want to unpack something about the idea of students seeking help. There are
- Students who say they need care but can actually cope
- Students who you know need care but say they can cope
- Students who you know need care and say they can't cope
Maybe a kid comes to you and tells you in very dramatic tones how terrible their life is because their phone got confiscated for a week, or they are not allowed to go to the concert on the weekend, or some kid called them an idiot after they made a joke about them.
Fundamentally here you have to remember that all students need care - you just got to choose the right kind of care. Don't reinforce annoying behaviours by treating a student with incredibly minor problems the same way in which you would with someone who has terrible problems. Look for ways in which you can provide other kinds of attention (Say hi to them, congratulate them for that award on assembly, giving them a job to complete etc) and talk to them about perspective in a caring way remembering that parents are not the only influence on students. Also, there is always the chance that your initial assessment could be wrong, so look for ways to see if it is a cry for help about a deeper issue that is not being talked about.
The second group is where I generally find I use my identification skills the most. It takes practise and being willing to be mistaken. I use the lines "Are you okay? (Expecting the answer to be yes) Well you just seem a little stressed/unhappy/worried." It gives them the opportunity to keep their dignity if there is a problem and if there is no problem then you haven't offended them. Since most adolescents do struggle with issues all the time, mostly it's like shooting fish in a barrel.
There is something about this group which implies that they are not used to getting people listening to them or something happened in the past where they sought help and things went bad. Tread carefully.
The third group is probably the most critical group. Most of the students who have problems and say "I have a problem and I'm not coping" wait until the problem is enormous and obvious. A lot of the time it revolves around parents fighting, being about to be kicked out of home, serious illnesses etc. Most of the time this is not a sit down and chat for a bit and see how you go kind of thing, but more of a "let's look at some strategies to get through today and then next week we'll touch base again." This is where I will raise the issue of reporting. We must all be aware of the guidelines of mandatory reporting. As soon as you get any idea that there is a possibility that a kid might tell you something reportable you have to warn them that if they tell you something bad you have an obligation to report. Do this in a way that is not going to discourage them from telling you but be clear that you will have to.
At the end of the day, if you are looking for kids to care for, you will find them. It's not rocket science, you can use behavioural science, but mostly you just have to be looking for kids to care for.
I always trust that God will show me who needs care and love and attention. I always trust that even though I can't care for everyone, that God will take care of the rest.